Blog Page

In recent years, a surprising pattern has emerged: technically strong CA rank holders struggling to crack investment roles.

One such instance in 2024 stands out. A bright CA fresher I mentored — an All India Ranker with solid command over DCF models and trading comps — was rejected by a boutique portfolio management firm. The hiring VP’s feedback was brutally honest:

“Technically sound, but couldn’t connect the dots. No sector view, no market conviction. Too focused on balance sheet hygiene. We need someone who can think like an investor, not an auditor.”

This wasn’t an isolated case. It’s a reflection of a larger gap between what the CA curriculum equips you for and what investment roles demand.

The Disconnect: CA Curriculum vs. Investment Role Expectations

The CA qualification builds deep expertise in financial reporting, tax, audit, and compliance. However, investment roles require a different mindset and skillset. Here’s how the two diverge:

What CA training focuses on:

• Mastery over Ind AS and regulatory standards
• Taxation laws and audit frameworks
• Strong understanding of historical financials

What investment roles require:

• Forward-looking analysis and sector narratives
• Understanding macro factors like MPC policy, FII/DII flows, interest rates
• The ability to explain why a stock or deal works — not just how it’s structured
• Sharp communication — pitching a thesis in 60 seconds to a CIO or fund manager

Knowing how to prepare a financial statement isn’t enough. Investment roles demand that you interpret data in the context of markets, business cycles, and investor sentiment.

The Good News: Transitioning Is Possible — If You Shift Your Approach

Many CAs do break into investment banking, equity research, or asset management — but they don’t rely on just their exam ranks or technical skills. They invest in market-readiness.

Here’s a proven roadmap for CA students looking to make that transition smoother:

• Start networking early: Leverage LinkedIn, alumni groups, and virtual conferences. Conversations open doors faster than cold CVs.
• Enroll in practical finance courses: Courses in Financial Modeling, M&A, or Equity Research bridge the skill gap and add credibility.
• Build a personal portfolio: Draft stock pitch decks or deal models. It shows initiative, market understanding, and the ability to apply concepts.
• Refine your communication: Learn to articulate your investment ideas clearly, with confidence and logic — not just technical jargon.
• Pursue CFA Level 1: It complements your CA foundation with global perspectives on portfolio management, ethics, and capital markets.

Final Thought: Speak the Language of the Buy-Side

This transition is not about choosing between CA and finance. It’s about adapting your toolkit. To thrive in investment roles, you need to speak a different language — the language of investors.

Not just Ind AS 116 or audit thresholds. Learn how to explain why a company deserves a “Buy” tag even at a 60x P/E multiple.

If you’re a CA student aiming for investment roles, the sooner you realign your preparation, the stronger your positioning will be.

Let’s Hear From You

Have you faced this challenge in your own career journey? Or helped someone through it?

Share your story or advice in the comments — because real insights always go beyond the textbook.

By CA Gaurav Jain

If you’re preparing for CA Final Advanced Financial Management (AFM), mastering concepts is just half the battle — the real challenge lies in presenting your answers the way ICAI examiners expect. Based on years of experience and examiner feedback, here’s a breakdown of answer writing strategies that can help you score an edge in CA Final AFM.

1️⃣ Understand What ICAI Examiners Expect

✅ Think like a Financial Consultant – Your answers must reflect clarity, professionalism, and decision-making, not just textbook knowledge.
✅ Strategic Presentation – Structure your answers with logic, not just steps.
✅ Content + Clarity = Success – Your marks depend not only on knowing the right answer, but on presenting it well.

2️⃣ Master the Calculation Format – Show it Neatly

Follow the 3-Step Rule:

1. Formula First – Clearly state the formula being used.
2. Substitute Values – Show the substitution of figures cleanly.
3. Final Answer – Write the final answer boldly, with correct units.

 Pro Tip: Use boxes and tables for organized, easy-to-read presentation.

3️⃣ Time Management is Crucial

⏱ Don’t Overdo Steps – Avoid unnecessary lengthy calculations.
⏱ Target: 1.8 Minutes per Mark – Pace yourself accordingly.
⏱ Be Crisp & Relevant – Stick to what’s asked, skip the fluff.

4️⃣ Add Value Through Interpretation

 Calculations alone won’t get you full marks. Add:

• Interpretation – What does the result mean?
• Logic – How does it impact business decisions?
• Example – “Positive NPV = Accept Project”

 Link your numbers to decision-making insights.

5️⃣ Tackle New or Unfamiliar Questions with Confidence

✅ Don’t Panic – New styles are expected.
✅ Justify Your Approach – Mention why you chose a particular method.
✅ State Your Assumptions – Clear assumptions show maturity.
✅ Logic Wins Marks – Even if your method is different, logical reasoning is rewarded.

6️⃣ Writing Theory = Use ICAI’s Language

For theory questions:

• Use ICAI Keywords from study material.
• Present in bullet points for clarity.
• Underline key points to guide the examiner’s eye.

This builds credibility and matches ICAI’s expectation style.

7️⃣ Follow ICAI’s RTP & MTP Formats

 Always refer to:

• RTPs (Revision Test Papers)
• MTPs (Mock Test Papers)
• Suggested Answers

✍️ Mimic the format used — it shows you’ve prepared in the ICAI’s preferred way and builds examiner confidence in your preparation.

Final Words from CA Gaurav Jain

“Answer writing is not just about solving the question. It’s about convincing the examiner that you are a future Chartered Accountant who thinks, writes, and presents like a professional.”

🛠 Whether it’s calculations or theory, your ability to balance accuracy, presentation, and logic is what truly earns marks in AFM.

Learn with CA Gaurav Jain

✅ Trusted by 1,00,000+ students
✅ ICAI Case Scenarios Coverage
✅ Full Theory, Question Bank & Concept Videos
👉 Check out our CA Final AFM Combo and MCQ Case Scenario Booklets on www.arihantca.com